- The main difference is structure. PAMM pools money under one manager, MAM and copy trading keep each investor's account separate, and a signal service only sends ideas.
- Control follows structure. In PAMM the manager decides for everyone, in MAM the manager sets each account's allocation, in copy trading you choose and can stop, and with signals you place every trade.
- None of them removes market risk. Check where the money sits, how the provider is paid and what record you can verify.
Copy trading, PAMM, MAM and signal services all let someone else guide your trading. They differ in who holds the money, who sets the size of your trades and how much control you keep. The short version: a PAMM pools investors’ money in one account, MAM and copy trading keep each investor’s account separate, and a signal service only sends ideas.
The four models side by side
| Signals | Copy | MAM | PAMM | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Account | Yours | Yours | Yours | A pool |
| Trades by | You | System | Manager | Manager |
| Size set by | You | Scaling | Manager | One ratio |
| Control | Full | Choose, stop | Per deal | Low |
| Use | Ideas | A strategy | Large sums | Passive |
What each one is
Signals. A provider sends trade ideas, often by messaging app, and you decide whether to place them. The word covers two different things. Alerts you act on by hand are signals in the usual sense. MetaTrader’s own Signals service lets subscribers copy a provider’s trades automatically, which makes it a form of copy trading.
Copy trading. The trades of a master are placed on your own account automatically, scaled to your balance. See what is copy trading?
MAM (multi-account manager). A manager trades many separate investor accounts from one place. Each investor keeps an individual account, and the manager sets how trades are allocated across them, for example by lot, balance or percentage.
PAMM (percentage allocation management module). Investors put money into one pooled account that a manager trades. Profit and loss are shared in proportion to each investor’s share of the pool, with one ratio for everybody.
A note on mirror trading. This is an older name for following a system’s trades automatically. Today the terms overlap, and platforms use them differently, so ask how the service places and sizes the trades.
Questions to ask about any of them
- Who holds the money? In your own account at your broker, or in a pool or an account that someone else controls?
- Who can trade it? What can the manager or the system do, and what can they not do?
- How is the provider paid? Performance fee, share of profit, spread, commission or subscription. Does the fee apply only to new profit above the previous high?
- What can you see and verify? A live record you can open yourself. How to read a Myfxbook record shows how.
- How do you leave? How fast can you stop, and what happens to open positions when you do?
- What happens in a loss? What does the agreement say about drawdown, and about losses beyond your deposit?
None of the models removes market risk. Is copy trading safe, and is it profitable? looks at the evidence.
Where Tradevia fits
Tradevia places a strategy’s trades on your own account at your broker, sized to that account. Structurally that is closest to copy trading: your own account, your own broker, and you can stop at any time. Tradevia is software. It does not hold your money and it does not run a pool. How regulators classify these models depends on the country and on who provides the service, so check the local rules, and speak to a licensed adviser if you need advice. For the practical steps, see copy trading on MT5.
Questions
Is copy trading the same as mirror trading?
The terms overlap and platforms use them differently. Ask how a service sizes and places the trades, and whether the account is yours.
Which one is best for a beginner?
There is no best model. If you want to choose and stop on your own, look at copy trading or signals. If you hand decisions to a manager, as in PAMM or MAM, you give up control, so read the agreement carefully.
Which one has the lowest costs?
It depends on the provider. Compare the fee types, such as performance fees, spreads, commissions and subscriptions, and work out what you would pay in a bad month and not only in a good one.
This is general information, not investment advice. Leveraged products can lose more than you deposit. Read the full risk disclosure