Learn

How to choose a copy trading master: 9 criteria

Nine checks before you copy a master. A live verified record, 26 weeks of history, drawdown beside return, consistency, how losses are handled, sizing, costs and conduct.

By Tradevia Desk Reviewed by Alex Nguyen Published 5 min read
Key takeaways
  • Choose on evidence you can check yourself. A live record, at least 26 weeks long, with drawdown shown beside return.
  • Look at how losses are handled. Growing position sizes and averaging down can hide risk behind a smooth curve.
  • The strategy also has to fit your account. Your balance, your broker's minimum lot and your costs decide whether you can copy it as it trades.

To choose a copy trading master, check nine things: that the record is real and live, long enough, shown with its drawdown, steady from month to month, honest about how losses are handled, copyable on your account, clear about costs, and run by someone whose conduct you can judge. No list predicts the future. This one filters out the weakest candidates before you put money in.

The nine criteria at a glance

#CriterionWhat to checkRed flag
1Verified live recordReal account, broker and server shown, record open to check on a third-party siteDemo or backtest only, screenshots, hidden account
2LengthAt least 26 weeks, ideally across different conditionsA short record sold with an annualised return
3Drawdown beside returnWorst fall next to the gain, with the basis statedA return quoted without any drawdown
4ConsistencyMonth-by-month results, number of losing monthsOne month explains most of the profit
5Handling of lossesAverage win against average loss, largest loss, position sizing patternSizes grow after losses, losers held far longer than winners
6Style and frequencySymbols, trades per day, holding timeStyle or symbols change during the record
7CopyabilityYour balance, minimum lot, spread and leverage at your brokerTypical trade falls below your broker’s minimum size
8Costs and incentivesHow the provider is paid and what you payThe provider earns more when you trade more
9Transparency and conductWho runs it, what changed, which account is shownThe account shown is not the one that is copied

The record: criteria 1 to 4

1. A verified live record

Look for a real account, with the broker and server visible, and a record that you can open yourself on a site the provider does not control. Demo results, backtests and screenshots are not a record. How to read a Myfxbook record explains what the badges on such a page do and do not prove.

2. A record that is long enough

Under 26 weeks, a record can be a lucky run. Tradevia does not annualise a record shorter than that, because compounding a short sample overstates what it proves. A good record also covers more than one kind of market: a trend, a range and a news shock.

3. Drawdown beside return

A return means little without what it cost to get there. A strategy that gained 40% with a 40% fall in the middle asked you to take far more pain than one that gained 40% with an 8% fall. Check which basis the drawdown uses, balance or equity. What is drawdown and why Myfxbook and MT5 can disagree cover this.

4. Consistency, month by month

Open the monthly results. If one month produced most of the profit, you are looking at luck or a one-off. Count the losing months and the longest losing run, and ask whether you could have lived through it.

The strategy: criteria 5 and 6

5. How losses are handled

Compare the average win with the average loss and look at the largest loss. Then look for patterns in the trade list:

PatternWhat it looks likeWhy it matters
Growing sizePosition size rises after a lossOne long losing run can erase the account
Averaging downSeveral positions opened against a moveProfit is small and frequent, the loss can be very large
Held losersLosing trades stay open far longer than winnersBalance looks smooth while floating loss builds up

None of these is wrong in itself, but they produce a smooth curve that can end in one large loss. Ask whether every position, or group of positions, has a defined exit and whether total exposure is capped.

6. Style and frequency

Know what it trades, how often and how long it holds. A strategy that trades dozens of times a day is far more sensitive to your spread and to delay than one that holds for days. If the style or the symbols change during the record, you are not looking at one strategy.

Your side: criteria 7 and 8

7. Can your account copy it?

Your trade size is scaled to your balance. Work out whether the strategy’s typical trade, scaled down to your account, stays at or above your broker’s minimum lot. If it does not, trades can be skipped and your results will differ from the record. Check the spread, leverage and the contract size too, which matters most for gold: see gold (XAUUSD) copy trading.

8. Costs and incentives

Find out how the provider is paid and what you pay: a subscription, a performance fee, a share of profit, or commission on volume. A provider paid on volume gains when you trade more. A fee charged only on new profit above the previous high is a different thing from one charged on every gain. Neither is automatically bad. You need to know which you have.

The person: criterion 9

9. Transparency and conduct

Who runs the strategy? How are changes announced? Is the same record still visible months later, or was the account replaced or reset? Does the provider run several accounts, and is the one shown the one that is copied? The account you see must be the account you would follow, at the size you would follow it.

How to use the list

Mark each criterion as pass, unclear or fail. A fail on criterion 1, 2 or 5 is a reason to stop. An unclear mark means ask, or wait. Compare at least three strategies with the same list, start with a small amount, and repeat the check every month, because records change.

Where Tradevia fits

On Tradevia’s strategy pages you can see the length of the record, the return and the drawdown side by side, and a link to the source record where one exists. That makes criteria 1 to 3 quick to check. Criteria 5 to 9 still need your own judgement. Read is copy trading safe, and is it profitable? before you decide how much to put in.

Questions

How many strategies should I compare?

At least three. A strategy looked at alone always seems fine. Use the same nine checks for each one.

Is the strategy with the highest return the best?

Not necessarily. The highest return often comes with the deepest drawdown. Compare the return with the worst fall, and ask whether you would have stayed through it.

How long should a record be before I copy?

Tradevia treats a record under 26 weeks as too short to annualise or to judge by return alone. Longer is better, and a record that includes a difficult period tells you more.

Should I copy the master with the best last month?

A single recent month is the weakest signal there is. Look at the whole record and at how the strategy behaved in its worst period.

Risk

This is general information, not investment advice. Leveraged products can lose more than you deposit. Read the full risk disclosure

Tradevia Desk
Editorial team