Proof

Myfxbook drawdown vs MT5: why one account shows two numbers

The same account can show a 5% drawdown on one basis and 40% on another. Balance, equity, deposits and timing explain the gap, with a worked example.

By Tradevia Desk Reviewed by Alex Nguyen Published 3 min read
Key takeaways
  • Myfxbook and MT5 can show very different drawdown for the same account. They differ on what they measure and on how they treat deposits and withdrawals.
  • In the MT5 reports we reconciled, the drawdown percentage ignored later deposits and withdrawals, which can inflate it several times over.
  • When you compare two numbers, ask four things. Balance or equity, how money moving in and out is treated, how often the account is sampled, and whether it is the same account and date.

Myfxbook and MetaTrader 5 (MT5) can show very different drawdown for the same account, because they measure different things in different ways. The main differences are the basis (balance or equity), how deposits and withdrawals are treated, and how often the account is sampled. None of these numbers is a mistake. Only some of them are comparable.

A worked example

This is an illustration with round numbers, not a real account. An account opens with 1,000. Trading lifts it to 1,200, a gain of 200. The owner then deposits 9,000, so the balance is 10,200. A losing run then takes 500 off the account, leaving 9,700.

MethodPeakLowDrawdown
Deposit treated as neutral: the 500 loss is measured against the 10,200 at work10,2009,7004.9%
Deposit ignored: balance is taken as the first deposit plus trading profit1,20070041.7%

The loss is the same 500 in both rows. It reads as 4.9% or as 41.7% depending on whether the 9,000 deposit is counted.

In the MT5 reports we reconciled, the drawdown percentages in the results block were computed like the second row: as if the balance were the first deposit plus cumulative trading profit, with later deposits and withdrawals left out. On an account that was built up through top-ups, that can print a figure several times larger than the real fall. The drawdown in money terms was much less affected than the percentage. If an account had deposits or withdrawals, do not copy the percentage from an MT5 report without checking it.

How the Myfxbook number behaves

Myfxbook does not publish its formula, so what follows is our finding from reconciling accounts, not Myfxbook’s documentation. Its Gain and Drawdown reproduced when we computed each trade’s return on the balance before the trade closed, left out deposits and withdrawals made while the trade was open, and then chained those returns together. In effect, money moving in and out is neutral: a deposit does not make a later loss look small, and a withdrawal does not make it look large.

Other reasons two numbers differ

  • Balance or equity. Balance moves when trades close. Equity includes the floating result of open trades and is usually deeper. See what is drawdown.
  • Positions that close in the same second. Strategies that close several positions at once can print a dip that never existed if the losing legs are counted before the winning ones, even though the group closed with a net gain.
  • Resolution. Myfxbook’s growth chart has one point a day. The headline drawdown is worked out from the trades, so the lowest point on the chart can be shallower than the number.
  • Fees and transfers. Some brokers post daily fees that a site may treat as withdrawals. Whether the fee counts as trading loss changes the result.
  • Cut-off date. Statements and sites update at different times. Compare numbers at the same date.
  • Currency. Cent accounts report money in cents, which makes money figures 100 times larger than the dollar value. Percentages are not affected. How to read a Myfxbook record shows where to look.

How to compare two drawdown numbers

  1. Is it the same account, at the same cut-off date?
  2. Is it the same basis, balance or equity?
  3. Did the account have deposits or withdrawals? If so, distrust any percentage that ignores them.
  4. Is it measured at the same resolution, every trade or once a day?
  5. Can you reproduce the number yourself from the trade list?

What Tradevia does

Where a strategy has a Myfxbook record, Tradevia shows the figure that the record shows, so you compare like with like. When Tradevia computes a figure itself, it follows the same method and says so in its methodology. A balance-based number leaves out the floating loss of open positions, so read it as a minimum. For the bigger picture, see how to choose a copy trading master.

Questions

Which is right, Myfxbook or MT5?

Neither is wrong, because they answer different questions. For a strategy's own trading result, a figure that treats deposits and withdrawals as neutral is the fairer guide, and that is how Myfxbook's figures behave as far as we could reproduce them. For the floating risk of open positions, look at equity.

Why does the Myfxbook chart look shallower than the drawdown number?

The growth chart plots one point a day, while the headline drawdown is worked out from the trades, so the deepest point on the chart can be shallower than the number.

Should I trust a drawdown quoted without a source?

No. Ask for the account, the cut-off date and the basis, then check whether the figure can be reproduced from the trade list.

Risk

This is general information, not investment advice. Leveraged products can lose more than you deposit. Read the full risk disclosure

Tradevia Desk
Editorial team